January 31, 2023

As the world reacts with horror to Pucha, China’s state media is attacking in a different tone

Editor’s note: A version of this story appeared in CNN’s newsletter in China meanwhile, with a three – weekly update a weekly exploring what you need to know about the country’s uprising and how it is affecting the world. Register here.

Hong Kong

Shocking pictures showing Bodies of civilians scattered in the streets Pucha, a suburb of the Ukrainian capital Kiev, has in recent days provoked global panic and raised the urgency of investigations into alleged Russian war crimes. But a completely different story is emerging in the Chinese state-run media.

The local media has reported about this Civilian casualties in Pucha Two major television reports on CCTV, which aired nationally this week, underscored Russia’s denial, highlighting unsubstantiated claims from Moscow that the situation had escalated after Russian troops withdrew from the area.

In a statement, a headline quoting Russia with the words “Ukrainians ran a good show” glowed in greatly dim scenes from the Ukrainian city.

There is no evidence to say so. Satellite images show some bodies have been there since at least March 18, while eyewitnesses said. The massacre began weeks ago.

Separately, the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights on Tuesday said that Pucha’s shocking pictures showed “all signs” that civilians were “directly targeted and directly killed.” On Tuesday, the UN. President Antonio Guterres has stepped up international calls for a war crimes inquiry into the killing of civilians in the city.

War allegations elevate China’s position. The apparent elevation of Beijing’s Russian campaign is in line with its position From the beginning of the invasion, It refuses to condemn Russia – at home or in its diplomacy – despite the increasing number of civilian deaths.

Instead, Beijing sought to portray itself as a neutral actor, while at the same time calling for peace. The situation is blamed on the United States.

This was shown in an editorial published in the nationalist newspaper Global Times on Wednesday, which, in quotations, called into question the “Pucha incident” and the authenticity of Russia’s acquittal.

“After the exposure of the ‘Pucha incident’, the United States, the initiator of the Ukraine crisis, showed no signs of pushing for peace and encouraging talks, but is ready to escalate Russia-Ukraine tensions, the editorial said.

“No matter what happens in the Pucha incident, no one can deny at least one thing: Bore is the main culprit in the humanitarian catastrophe,” it added.

In the weeks leading up to Russia’s invasion, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping announced that there were “no limits” to their partnership, and rising tensions with the United States have brought Moscow and Beijing closer in recent years.

Has been in Beijing since the Russian invasion Will come under considerable pressure Condemn Russia’s actions and impose sanctions on countries around the world. Chinese officials have instead refused to use the word “invasion” to describe Russia’s actions.

On Tuesday, the UN. At a special session of the Security Council, Chinese Ambassador Zhang Jun acknowledged that the images of civilian deaths in Pucha were “deeply concerned” but urged “all sides” to “exercise restraint” when blaming the situation. Avoid unsubstantiated allegations.

“The circumstances and specific causes of the incident must be verified and established. Any allegation must be based on facts,” Zhang said.

Foreign Ministry spokesman Wang Wenbin made similar comments at a regular conference on Wednesday, saying “humanitarian issues should not be politicized.”

Before discovering the truth, Wang said, “all parties must exercise restraint and avoid baseless accusations,” adding that China is “ready to continue working with the international community to prevent any harm to the public.”

But domestically, China, Russia and the Chinese state media have been broadcasting news that goes hand in hand with a long history – including the conduct of anti-Russian protests, the emergence of pro-Hong Kong pro-democracy struggles and Govt-19 – that seeks to deny the character of Western officials and the media.

On Tuesday, the state-run China News Service posted a similar post on Weibo, a popular social media site such as Twitter, with the hashtag “Russia shows video to prove Pucca incident took place.” Russian state news agency.

But as China amplifies Russian rhetoric in its domestic reporting, you can find some public skepticism on even China’s most moderate social media sites.

In a recent example, a military blogger who was widely followed on Sunday wrote that the Ukrainians were responsible for the “civilian massacre” – but in the comments below, many users suggested that the details of the post were incorrect.